Best Handmade Soaps | Amish Country Soap Co® Best Sellers

250 Years of Soap Making Tradition | Best Selling Soaps

Discover what our customers love most. Each product in this Best Sellers Collection is handmade by our family in Amish Country, Ohio, using pure oils and time-tested methods passed down for ten generations. No harsh chemicals—just real soap that’s gentle on your skin and kind to the earth. Whether you’re searching for a signature scent or a perfect gift, start here with our most-loved soaps, salves and moisturizers.  These are our Best Sellers.

Best Handmade Soaps | Amish Country Soap Co® Best Sellers
 
Beeutiful | Bar Soap

Beeutiful 4 oz Bar Soap – Natural Eczema, Acne & Psoriasis Relief | Amish Country Soap Co.

From $5.50
 
Handmade oatmeal honey bar soap – natural sensitive skin soap

Oatmeal Honey Handmade Bar Soap – Gentle, Sensitive Poison Ivy Formula

From $5.50
 
Lavender Petals | Bar Soap 4oz

Lavender Handmade Bar Soap – Natural Cold Process, Essential Oils

From $5.50
 
Patchouli Peace | Bar Soap 4oz

Patchouli Handmade Bar Soap – Natural Cold Process Soap

From $5.50
 
Love Me | Bar Soap 4oz

Jasmine White Lily & Cherry | Love Me Handmade Bar Soap – Floral Cold Process

From $5.50
 
Vanilla acai berry handmade bar soap – cold process natural soap

Beach Nut Vanilla & Acai Berry Handmade Bar Soap – Natural Cold Process

From $5.50
 
3 Magi | Premier Bar Soap 4oz

Amish Country Soap Company 3 Magi Frankincense Pain Relief Bar Soap

From $9.00
 
Handmade lemongrass bar soap – cold process essential oil soap

Lemongrass Handmade Bar Soap – Refreshing Cold Process Soap

From $5.50
 
Oh-Naturale’ | Bar Soap 4oz

Unscented Sensitive Skin Handmade Bar Soap | Oh Naturale' Natural Cold Process

From $5.50
 
Dirty Boy | Pumice Soap 4oz

Dirty Boy | Pumice Soap 4oz

From $5.50
 
Charcoal Detox | Bar Soap 4oz

Activated Charcoal Bar Soap| Lavender, Lemongrass, Tea Tree

From $9.00
 
Rosemary Spearmint Soap | Bar Soap

Rosemary Spearmint Handmade Bar Soap – Refreshing Cold Process

From $9.00
 
Purple Pastures Bar Soap
Save $3

Lavender Oatmeal Beef Tallow Soap | Purple Pastures | Amish Country Soap Company

From $9.00 $12.00
 
Frankincense Myrhh Cinnamon Bark Shampoo Bar

3 Magi Shampoo Bar | Frankincense Myrhh Cinnamon Bark

$12.00